Fear of Commitment: Looking for the Perfect Bookmark and File Sharing Site

I have a fear of commitment…to bookmarking sites.

Maybe I’m too picky. I’m waiting for the “Holy Grail” of sites: The free site that easily organizes both documents and websites and then pushes those items to my mobile devices. I want to put everything in one place – for free. I dream that this perfect system will one day appear on my dashboard and it will be love at first sight.

Then again, maybe I’m not “getting out there enough.” How can I meet the perfect site if I keep haunting my favorite hangouts?

I’ve ventured out a bit. I subscribed to iCloud, Delicious, and Dropbox. I suppose my interactions with those sites were more like speed-dating. I haven’t taken time to switch all bookmarks and files to an online format. Some of my grad school bookmarks are in Delicious, some are not. I can’t remember which ones are where. I have lists of links in document files that I may or may not have dropped into Dropbox. If I dropped by those sites, would they still remember me?

So, as I read articles like Summer PD: A Primer on Compiling Digital Resources by Mary Beth Hurtz, I wondered if I will ever find the perfect match. Can one site keep all my files and bookmarks in a single location where they can be shared with colleagues and students?

But the question extends beyond me: Am I passing this fear of commitment on to innocent students? If I can’t keep my own bookmarking systems straight, how can I teach my students to fall in love with a system of digital organization?

What do my students (and me) really need? Here are a list of my “Must Have”s:

  1. Simplicity. The fewer clicks, the better. More clicks = more potential for distraction.
  2. Shared access so that both teachers and students can add links. My email box is already flooded with emails. Many of my students are eager to share links with me. They email the links and I generally add them to a second, third, and fourth email that is re-sent to all my students. I’ve also added links to my classroom website or my school intranet page. Given Web 2.0, I no longer want to manually do what students are fully capable of doing.
  3. Global access. I’m an expat teacher working with students who travel extensively. The first semester, my 5th grade students are not allowed to take their laptops home. They need to access their bookmarks so they don’t have to email site links to themselves.
  4. Longevity. I wish I had a crystal ball that could tell me which sites will be around forever. I don’t want bookmarks to disappear when computers are re-imaged. I don’t want to switch bookmarks from site to site.
  5. Student anonymity. I get nervous about anything that requires email sign-in. I become hypocritical if I ask students to be careful with personal information and then ask them to use their email address to sign up for a bookmarking site.
  6. Ideally, both files and bookmarks can be shared in the same place.
In an attempt to “get out there” and look for my organizational love, I have analyzed some options:
File sharing:

Bookmarking sites:

Combination file sharing and bookmarking sites:

I see some potential mates. But, my ideal would probably be a combination of LiveBinders (with free, unlimited storage) and Diigo. Until those are combined, I’m most tempted to continue my relationship with Dropbox, adding documents that students can access/share for the sole purpose of adding links (and descriptions of the links).

That said, I’m always open to input from my colleagues and readers. I need to know two things:

1. Are any of my tables (above) incorrect? If so, let me know.
2. Am I missing anything? What have been your experiences with file sharing and bookmark sharing?

Also, I realize tables are difficult to read. Sign up for updates by email and I’ll send you a .pdf version.

11 thoughts on “Fear of Commitment: Looking for the Perfect Bookmark and File Sharing Site

  1. Love the title of your post! I, too, have a fear of commitment – not that I don’t want to commit, but I am that perfectionist who, like you, wants the perfect tool designed to meet my needs before I commit. That’s the reason that I waited until this Christmas to finally choose an eReader (Kindle).

    I used to use Delicious, but found that Diigo meets my needs much more easily.

    Love, love, love Dropbox. I do wonder about longevity, but since they offer premium accounts and I know educators who have purchased them, I feel pretty safe using it (still in the free stage). Dropbox has a mobile app, so I am able to open documents on my iPhone. I no longer carry a flashdrive with me.

    Love Evernote, too. Again – premium accounts are available. And a mobile app.

    Are these tools perfect – and perfect for me? Perhaps not, but I have learned to make them work for me. And that is the bottom line for me.

  2. I use Dropbox and Evernote for different purposes. I use Evernote to create new notes (text and image) while I use Dropbox to store documents I want ready access to on all of my devices. I’m more of a long document than note kind-of-gal (former English teacher!) which leads me to go on and on about Dropbox.

    A school librarian friend of mine, Heather Loy, loves Evernote. I think it’s a personal preference.

    By the way, three of us SC school librarians (Heather Loy, Cathy Jo Nelson, and myself) have presented a session called “There’s an App for That” in three different venues. I focus on creating a personal start page using iGoogle, Cathy discusses Dropbox, and Heather discusses Evernote.

  3. Pingback: Research 2.0 = Searching + Evaluating + Annotating + Sharing + Collaborating | Expat Educator

  4. Thanks for pointing me to your post! I, too, have my stuff spread out all over because there’s not one tool for the job. I used to use Delicious in my lab. Then I moved to PortaPortal and now I’m pondering LiveBinders and Symbaloo.

    Your approach is spot on. We don’t want to fall in love with the tool, we want to fall in love with what it does. Then, if that tool goes away, at least we know what we’re looking for!

  5. Pretty great post. I simply stumbled upon your blog
    and wanted to mention that I’ve truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. After all I’ll
    be subscribing on your rss feed and I’m hoping you write again soon!

  6. My brother recommended I would possibly like this web site.
    He used to be totally right. This put upp actually madxe my day.
    Youu cann’t imagine simply how soo much time I had spent for this info!

  7. I blog frequently and I genuinely appreciate your information. The article has really peaked my interest.
    I am going to take a note of your website and
    keep checking for new information about once a week.
    I opted in for your Feed as well.

Please add your thoughts, opinions, and questions.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s